It's so much more enjoyable to watch Hana & Alice on screen together with each other, than to see them apart, and that's probably why I found this one to be so much fun to watch. Their dynamic and friendship is so endearing and they play off of each other so well, with Alice being eccentric and outgoing, while Hana is the silent, brooding type. For some reason, I am always enamored with Shunji Iwai's storytelling, it's loose and it's even confusing at times, but his characters really make it worthwile, most of the time anyway. Moreover, I honestly think Iwai does a pretty damn good job at making more lighthearted, slice-of-life-esque films, even if he's more well known for his more thought provoking and serious films. Hell, "A Bride For Rip Van Winkle" is ranked top 5 in my favorite movies list, but I think Iwai has a knack for creating such enjoyable, fun, characters with such special quirks that make them interesting, rather than flat characters.
Alice has got to be one of my all-time favorite Iwai characters now... she is just so sweet and silly and even when watching the first movie, I was always rooting for her hard. However, while I wasn't the biggest fan of Hana watching the first movie, I feel like getting to see more of her character here made me understand her and like her a lot more than I initially did. By just watching the first movie, you do see a lot of Hana and Alice, both together and separately, and get a lot of insight into their characters, such as Alice's home life, and Hana's delusion and dedication to romance, but being able to see more of these two made me love them even more. I don't think there was ever a part of me that thought a prequel was unnecessary to the story, and I really loved how Iwai made sure to include settings and stories from the first movie for consistency sake. Background characters like Fuko or Alice's dad are still featured, which I thought was pretty neat for them to keep in.
Circling back on a previous point, I wish the first movie had given Hana and Alice more time onscreen together, rather than apart, but I imagine that wasn't initially thought of while making the movie. Ironically, most people focused on Hana and Alice's somewhat brief on screen friendship versus the love triangle plot line that took up most of the runtime in the first one. If people didn't enjoy the first film as much, I imagine they'd find this one much more enjoyable, if slice of life stuff is more their style. The animation was a little wonky at times, since it's rotoscoped, but I genuinely didn't find it unbearable or unwatchable! The backgrounds were absolutely beautiful though. Watch this movie!!! Watch both movies!!! Especially if you like more lighthearted, slice of life type stuff.
i'll stop the tangential rant here before i get too open about private things, but this movie really was a way for me to help relieve some of the grief and pain i suffered with the past year. some people found this movie to be disrespectful, perhaps even full of itself and too messy, but i'm not a film critic so my views on films are probably asinine! like i said, i've experienced this before, almost eerily in the same way, so i didn't find anything within this terribly dishonest or poorly handled. that being said... i'll agree with others that i found the daughter and the random missionary boy storyline to be unneccessary, or rather just lame. both characters i did not care for whatsoever, not sure if that's the acting speaking or the writing. hong chau's character i actually resonated with because it felt pretty similar to how i was when i was caretaking for my family, the absolute misery of watching someone you so desperately want to stay, quietly go out. i think the actors here did the best they could with what they were given, and i don't find it entirely a bad thing. i think my own personal experiences influenced my view on this one, and i wonder if i were to ever revisit this, would i still view it the way i do now?
Took me awhile to get used to the filming style for this movie, the shakey camera and abrupt zoom-ins, but I think it made the film feel much more personal, very real. I have to admit that in the first half of the movie, I found Bjork's acting to be strange until the movie developed and I could see that she is capable of showcasing so much pain and misery in more than just her music. Then again, maybe I'm just a sucker for Bjork's vocal range. Selma screaming for help as her face is covered by the shawl as she awaits to be hung was so terrifying to me because I felt as though her fear was palpable, like I knew the feeling of suffocation. I don't think this movie would work with anyone else but Bjork, and I think her performance covers up a lot of flaws in this one, but nonetheless I loved this one. Maybe it's just because I'm hormonal, but this one definitely got a tear out of me, which is incredibly rare. Bravo!
lisa as a character was so interesting, a woman who created a life for herself as the doting, lovable wife and mother at the expense of her love for the arts. was lisa really just a spectator in the world of art, or was she merely just trying to live the life she had really wanted for herself? her poetry is seen as ordinary, bland and repetitive, chockful of metaphors that try to come off as deep and meaningful, in contrast to her 5-year old student who is capable of crafting beautiful poems off the top of his head. lisa's children are archetypical highschool students, who view doing good in life through grading systems or acts of heroism, but lisa wishes they were something more, that they were inventive and passionate about something that was not expected of them. lisa sees her own failings as a mother through her children and the children she teaches because she sees her own life through them, and believes they all could have possibly created beautiful things. that's my theory, anyway. can any child become mozart if you tried hard enough? were we all capable of being child prodigies at some point, or is it really just a game of chance? lisa tries her hardest to keep the flame she sees in her student alive, sometimes pushing the limits of morality, because she knows that one day he will be expected to pursue a life of academics and labor, stifling the flame.
i really really loved this one, as hard as it was to watch, because i wish i was more creative, more inspired and motivated to create art that i can find value in. i envy the mind i used to have when i was younger, someone who wasn't so afraid to create!
anyways, getting back to the actual review, the last 30 minutes or so of the movie was infinitely better than the build-up to it, i found it really predictable but i didn't hate it for that. i won't spoil it, but if you like movies like "it follows" or the ring series, this did pretty okay for that trope. it was basically like a much better version of that one really bad horror movie, "truth or dare", i wonder how much lucy hale got paid for that... i think the only part i really found amazing was the body horror, i'm a big fan of that when it comes to horror films. i didn't really like the ending scene, i had a much better idea for what they could have done, but i'm too lazy to find a way to hide spoilers through code, so i won't go any further with that. i'll end this review by repeating something my friend brought up, which is that we should have intermissions during movies where people can take bathroom breaks or what have you, like the opera. don't force me to hold my bladder!
first impressions, i was initially very confused in the first 30 minutes, but i did not care because elizabeth taylor and mia farrow are amazing actresses. i was so obsessed with mia's character, "cenci", and just how creepy and kooky she was. i love weird girls!!! i was so interested in the dynamics between cenci and leonora and how they both on some level understood they were only deluding themselves for their own benefits, but the audience isn't made aware of this for most of the film. i love any sort of plot that centers around mother and daughter relationships/dynamics, and this was nothing short of that. besides all that, the settings for the film were all so ethereal and dreamy, i want one of those music boxes so bad. i think the film sort of dipped near the ending, but the eventual build-up where both characters are forced to drop the act and realize their fantasies were unwinding was so intense and enthralling. anyways, i hope albert really did die in the ending.
throughout the entire film i wondered what the script for this looked like, and what the actresses thought of it. i did not recognize mia until i finished, but i'm definitely going to watch rosemary's baby now that i've gotten a taste of how well of an actress she is, especially in psychological horror settings. i think this film would definitely be a miss for a general audience, but unfortunately it worked so well for me because i'm a lover of all things weird and eerie. i'm unsure if i'd ever really recommend this to anyone, probably a movie you just have to discover for yourself. overall, a strange and uncomfortable, yet intriguing film.
i don't think i've ever been invested so much into a movie for a long time, and i could not believe this random, early 2000's french film had me practically glued to the screen. typically when i go into a movie like this, i imagine that most of it will suck, and that the one scene i watched it for was not worth the time wasted at all, but this one subverted every expectation i've ever had! not only is it a musical (which made me laugh so hard when the first opening number came on out of nowhere), but it's also a "whodunit" comedy that is actually very unpredictable. anytime you think you know where the plot may be going, something else happens that was nowhere in the realm of possibilities. this movie also opened me to the world of french actresses, such as fanny ardent, catherine deneuve and isabelle huppert, as well as their league of online lesbian fans. i don't want to spoil this one because if this ever somehow inspired someone to watch it, you have to go into it with no deep knowledge of the plot to really enjoy it to it's full potential. even if the plot was predictable, i'd have still ended up enjoying it because the characters were all so uniquely written and i think the actresses on the film did an amazing job portraying them. also, the movie takes place around christmas, what is not to love about that! i am not kidding when i say this is a near perfect film to me, an all women, christmas themed, musical murder mystery! (rating: 5/5 stars)